Saturday, July 9, 2011

BR: The Pink Locker Society- The Forever Crush

by Debra Moffitt
The Pink Locker Society; book III

I haven't heard of the website this book originated from, but I had some ideas. It looked light-hearted so I gave it a shot.

Summary (goodreads)

When the going gets tough, the tough get ... pink!

Someone wants the Pink Locker Society gone, but Jemma and her BFFs are sticking together.

"Shut down the PLS - or else!" A mysterious someone keeps sending Jemma, Kate, and Piper threatening messages, but they won’t stop the Pink Locker Society. They know the girls at their middle school need them. Who else will answer their questions about everything from bras to boys? And, the truth is, Jemma has just (secretly) submitted a question of her own. It's about Forrest, her forever crush. He asked her to be his pretend girlfriend and she said yes! Jemma promised to tell no one the truth about their relationship, but can she keep it from everyone, including her best friend, Kate? Not that Kate seems to have noticed - she's suddenly obsessed with whether people think she's fat. Beautiful Piper doesn’t need to worry about that. She just wants to know if Forrest and Jemma have kissed. But does a real kiss with your pretend boyfriend still count?

My Expectations: Somewhere in the so-so area, I didn't think I'd fall in love with it.
Delivery: Kind of what I expected, I didn't really think it was my thing.
Put-down-ability: 6/10

My Thoughts

I feel The Pink Locker Society: The Forever Crush targets a pretty specific audience, and quite frankly, I just wasn’t it. It’s a book for tween girls and I think if I was 11, I’d find it extremely relatable and helpful. However, since I’m not 11, I didn’t particularly care for it.

I just couldn’t get myself to connect with Jemma—and maybe it’s my whole snobby teenager thing, but she just reminded me of eighth graders (which she was) but honesty, once you’re out of grade eight, you spend the rest of high school hating grade eights…. I swear :p To me, her worries just seemed trivial and immature but I know that when I was younger, her concerns totally made up my world too.

I liked the fact that Moffitt made sure the story had an interesting storyline as well as a strong, even inspirational message. I admired Jemma’s realizations and the way she handled things in a mature yet still relatable manner. There were times when I thought Moffitt tried to tackle too much at once with too many sub-plots, whether it was her parent’s pregnancy, the healthy weight issues, the crush, the hater, or snotty people in general; some parts just felt pushed to the side then snatched back out of nowhere.

The Forever Crush would be an awesome book for tween girls, I think it dealt with subject matter that’s especially relevant that demographic, but it just wasn’t for me. I’d totally recommend it for moms to buy for their daughters, or if you’re a fan of middle-grade, lesson-learning fiction, this one’s great.

Rating in HP Terms: Acceptable
Recommended for: girls, maybe ages 8-14
Acknowledgements: none

7/10 – because I couldn’t get myself to care for the things going on her life, such as a pretend boyfriend. I know I’m not really the ideal reader for a book like this, but nevertheless it was enjoyable at times and I thought all the subject matter in the book was handled well by the author. It’s the kind of book I’d totally devour if I was younger though!

source: publisher
Pink Locker Society / Kids Health


  1. You're smart, girl. And brave -- I probably wouldn't have picked something up that seemed so trivial. Glad there were at least SOME parts that you enjoyed :)

  2. LOL, I probably wouldn't have picked up this book since i'm past the age range :) and I don't like eighth graders much myself- too loud :)

  3. Sounds likes a cute and fun read if you are a middle grader :)

  4. I'll ask my little cousin if she has heard of this one. I think she would enjoy it.

    Kudos to you for giving it a try.


for those who are confused, it means "Don't forget to be AWESOME". *hugs*